On
this very day 65 years ago Mahatma was assassinated. Today two things made
headlines-Kamalhasan’s Viswaroopam was not allowed to release in Tamilnadu even
after clearance from Madras High Court and Censor Board. Out of frustration,the
most admired actor of India has announced in a press conference that he may have
to leave the country to live in a secular state as was done earlier by a world
renowned Indian Painter MF Hussain. Salman Rashide another great Indian born
writer of Midnight Children was not permitted to enter Kolkata fearing
violence.
Three
days back another UP Minister declared in a public meeting that he would have
led a demonstration to destroy the TAJ to show the world how pubic money should
not be wasted and to demonstrate that he is a champion of the common tax payer.
Ironically, it is a state where big monuments and public parks are constructed
for a living person only recently and this champion was not known to have
protested but want to rewrite history of 500 years. Fortunately, he did not ask
to remove in text books Shahjahan’s name for the sin he committed. I would not
be surprised if immediately a committee will be constituted to consider the
demand. I wish the above is an overstatement. But I am not feeling that way
because cartoons of 1950 by great cartoonist Sankar were removed from NCERT
text books because our parliamentarians felt that they were showing Nehru and Ambedkar
in poor light. The great leaders themselves never felt that way in their times
and in fact one story says Nehru was even joking with Sankar when the next
cartoon on him would appear.
Recently
I was talking to a group of young people who have completed their engineering
and some of them are even working. In between
the discussion I asked them to tell about Mahatma. Some were able to
recollect the date and year of birth, death, Independence day etc. Fortunately
all were able to tell that under his leadership India
attained Independence .
One intelligent guy declared that bandhs, disruptions, damage to public
property during protests which are taking place today had roots in freedom
struggle. Immediately my blood boiled. But then I thought who is to be blamed for
this. The parents are never allowing them to read anything else other than
EAMCET, IIT, CAT etc coaching material. For them Mahatma and freedom struggle
are considered distractions, hamper their success and obstacles for the student’s
growth. Even during the British Regime history of the nation as well as the Great Britain and their colonies from the known
periods of origin and besides Basic Geography were taught in schools and
colleges in India .
Albert
Einstein a great scientist of all times had predicted that world would not believe that a man like Mahatma lived on this earth, walked and talked with
fellow human beings. But even that great scientist did not predict that he
will be considered irrelevant in his own country by future generations so early
after his demise.
I am
writing so early because 65 years is too little considering the recorded
civilization of more than 5000 years in India .
These
young people are taking democracy and liberty enjoyed in India for
granted as if nothing can disturb it. British Empire
which lasted for 200 years covering half of the world collapsed in a span of 30
years. Moghul Empire also lasted for 200 years before its collapse. Even a
Mighty USSR which was talking in equal terms with US during cold war era
collapsed and divided into four to five countries after 75 years. Marxism which
inspired lot of young people for more
than 100 years exists now only in the name of some Indian parties.
It
is all the more difficult to think otherwise when out of two major political
parties one could not find a better candidate than a seemingly reluctant
dynastic leader and other one could not find a leader other than the person
whose secular credentials are not beyond suspicion by his own party colleagues.
We need not blame only these two. Other parties are also feeling dynastic rule
as natural and some of the heir apparents claiming the right over their party
as if it is an ancestral property. Fortunately courts are yet to entertain such
cases.
Our
finance minister, RBI and financial experts are concerned that gold imports are
increasing and are second only to most
essential crude oil. Ironically, India ranks very low in human
development index. India
produces a very little gold. Though one of the largest economies still it has
the largest poor population in the world. Even as RBI and Government are trying
all other failed methods like increasing taxes which only encourage smuggling, banks
and other financial institutions are advertising to buy gold with attractive
gold loan schemes. But none of our political class has the courage to appeal to
people to reduce gold consumption in these difficult times. Compare this with
Mahatma’s preaching of boycotting foreign goods and former Prime Minister Lal
Bahadur Sastry’s appeal for skipping one meal in a week.
Rave
parties and pub culture of youth to exhibit their freedom (some of them are
financed by their own parents) also raise questions about true nature of
freedom and whether we really deserve freedom brought by the sacrifices under
the leadership of Mahatma.
Adolf
Hitler writes in Mein Kampf that teaching and studying history does not mean
memorizing some important dates and the names of rulers or reciting some
doctrines. History reading means studying the process involved leading to those
events,causes, effect of those events,
relevance of these events and learning from them for the present day society.
HG Wells
writes about preserving historic events
with an example on Buddhism. Disciples
of Buddha preserved the tree under which Gautama
attained enlightenment. But they could not preserve the eight fold path
prescribed by him. Otherwise Buddhism or
for that matter world would have been different today.
Every
political party mentions RamaRajya in its manifesto but follows Coalition
Dharma not Sanatana Dharma after coming to power. According to this Dharma
everything can be condoned and pardoned in the name of preserving coalition.
Blinking is more virtuous than awakening. Sidestepping is more valued than
facing the problem. All great debates take place on TV screen while Parliament meets
for passing condolence resolutions or for adjournments to the next day. Every
political party agrees on some issues outside the parliament but sees to it
that the bill is not introduced in the house. Majority of the members oppose
some issues but see to it that the bill is passed so that the government of the
day should not be embarrassed. Even the members of major opposition parties abstain
from important voting by taking an excuse of more urgent work than expressing
the will of the people they represent.
Like
these many things can be written and pages can be filled. So, at this juncture
Mahatma’s philosophy is more relevant than any other time.
Our
politicians must realize the consequences of stopping free expression. A film
is banned after clearance from a respected body like censors and justifying the
ban by announcing that it may antagonize the feeling of some groups thereby
create law and order problems. These people should just refer to American
Declaration of Independence authored by Thomas Jefferson and others which is
the fore-runner for all modern day democracies. The fate that is deserved by
the government which cannot protect liberty is clearly mentioned. No
civilization has grown without somebody questioning the existing practices.
Questions may be right or wrong but the right to question is never throttled in
India .
As Nobel Laurette Amartyasen has written that Caravaka and Gautama Buddha questioned. But they were never stopped from questioning.
In fact India
is proud that there is no Galileo unlike in the west even in ancient times.
Just imagine Mahatma did not question untouchability or British Government
stopped it taking shelter under creating unrest among upper classes.
Mahatma
never asked his followers to destroy public places to show the might of the
movement. In fact, he stopped the freedom struggle when an innocent mob had
torched a police station in a remote village in Bihar, much to the dismay of
the greatest admirers of Mahatma because of his belief that a seed sown
somewhere might grow into big tree which cannot be rooted out.
Criticism
of Mahatma was never discouraged. Even Jawaharlal Nehru criticized Mahatma when
Bihar earthquake and untouchability were
linked by Mahatma. Gandhi’s policy of non-violence was protested by Netaji. Surprisingly,
Netaji won the congress presidential election against the nominee supported by
Mahatma. Difference of opinion was always
respected in India .
Atheism is as old as Vedas writes Amartyasen in Argumentative Indian.
Some
leaders across all parties have given statements questioning the girl of the
requirement to travel in a bus in the capital in recent sensational gang rape case
only to deny it next day and defending again at some other place. Let us set
aside a moment of Mahatma’s definition of freedom that a true freedom is a time when a woman can move alone in the middle of
night.But let us talk about their convictions. Compare this with Mahatma’s.
Mahatma was asked to deny a statement in the court by a judge. He even
requested Gandhi at least to apologize, so that he is spared from giving
punishment to the great person. Instead, Mahatma asked the judge to do his
duty.
It
looks silly to mention here at a time that GO’s are made, unmade, tampered,
alignment of roads are changed,
bureaucrats and intelligentia work overtime to serve the interest of their sons
and their political masters only to blame each other in case the scam becomes
open and sons of even honourable judges are involved in taking bribes for
arranging bail in a much publicized case whereas Mahatma disowned one of his
son’s only because his behavior was improper. But is it not a laughing matter
that our country is ranked 94th in Transparency International’s
corruption index and 134th in the latest human development index of
United Nations and the country’s Youth is indifferent to these figures and are
only interested and browbeat about their CTCs and pay packets.
Gandhiji
went abroad for higher studies. This is not a news to be written for the
present day generation when NRIs are one of largest immigrant community living
in US and parents aspire to send their children to US or get
married their daughters to a green card holder. But 120 years back crossing the
ocean was a taboo for a traditional Indian. Gandhi could persuade his parents,
but only after promising his mother that he would never touch wine, other women
or take meat. Putlibai did not ask
for dollars or wealth but good behavior. For modern day parents every thing that
is American is green, but they cannot digest when any young boy or girl dates
like their American counterparts. But they fail to teach the good behavior.
Mahatma writes in his autobiography that even after lot of practice he almost came near to
breaking the promise before remembering his word to his mother. Here is a
lesson of parenting for every parent and behavior for every child.
Gandhiji
is totally identified with freedom struggle by text book history. This did a
great disservice to the nation or mankind. Because the young generation is
identifying with him as a politician only, ignoring more important spiritual
quality in him. Another important thing ignored is his transnational character.
He fought against South African apartheid as well and he did it much before
coming to India and only at
the age of 46 he came back to India .
First seed of rebellion against the racism was also sown in him only in South Africa . His Phoenix Ashram in
Durban is as famous
as Sabarmati or Sevagram. His patriotism did not prevent him from making
friendship with Europeans including British nationals and he was always
surrounded by some white people. His first and fundamental policy was to protest
the bad behavior in the person, without hating him like a true sanatanist. When
whole India
was celebrating the Independence Gandhiji was mourning for the people who were
killed in partition riots. For him Hindu Muslim Unity and eradicating the untouchability
were far ahead in his priorities than freedom. Just before his assassination
also, he was on fast and one of the demands was to pay the money to Pakistan that
was promised during the partition. He predicted the consequences of partition of
India
and tried his best to avoid it. World is facing the result of it and source of
terrorism anywhere in the world has its roots in the region and this region is
always at the receiving end of the scourge. Apart from this there were three
wars between two countries and one of the countries divided again. The basic
reason for which the country was born could not keep it united and the Sub continent
is always on the boil. Leaders of two nations shaking hands is news of the
world and for a casual statement on Jinnah a leader like LK Advani has to face
the wrath of the many people. Every statement by one nation is always viewed
with suspicion by the other and gives scope for other nations to fish in
troubled waters. It is clearly proving Mahatma’s prediction that partition
would not solve problems but fuel further problems.
His
love for humanity was best exemplified by the letter written by him to Hitler
addressing him as Dear Friend. He explains in the letter addressing him as
friend should not surprise Hitler because a man like Gandhi cannot have
enemies. He further writes that both were fighting against the same power but it does not stop
him from condemning the behavior of the dictator
as it threatens the very existence of humanity. He tried to teach the virtues
of non violence to the great dictator.
Another
big mistake in our text books is ignoring his spiritual character. With a peep
into a few pages of My Experiments with Truth we will realize that he followed
more spiritual path than political. His detractors were always complaining that
his apolitical behavior would create more harm to the struggle rather than serving
it and no political goal could be achieved through spiritual path he followed.
But he never deviated from it and he openly declared many a time that he
follows Santana dharma. He had always avoided anything that is slightly against
Sanatana Dharma.Yet it didn’t prevent him from befriending people of all
religions and none of them, not even
Jinnah suspected his secular credentials. At the same time he fought fiercely
against sanatanists for eradicating untouchability. After reading few pages we
will realize that he would have made a better spiritual leader than a political
leader. In fact he had his Ashrams three famous ones (1) Phoenix
in Durban South Africa (2) Sabarmati near
Ahmedabad (3) Sevagram near Wardha. But
from them, living spiritual life led all types of struggles- political, industrial
and spiritual struggles.
Many
people and leaders did not believe initially that his truth and non-violence
could bring freedom. But one by one including Lalalajpatroy of Lal Bal Pal fame (one of militant wing) became admirers of
Mahatma is a text book itself on leadership and I have not come across any book
on personality development or leadership written by any author or any countryman
without mentioning Mahatma even once. But unfortunately none of our Youth even do
not correctly remember or try to study about him.
Another
criticism on Gandhi is that he was against industrialization and only wanted
village industries. There cannot be anything far from truth. If he was totally
against industrialization, business legends at that time like GD Birla, Kasturibhai
Lalbhai and Ambalal Sarabhai would not have come near him nor he would have
entertained them given his nature. These people were ardent admirers of Mahatma
itself shows his view about industrialization. There were times when Jawaharlal
viewed them with suspicion but not Gandhi. At the same time he had seen in his
stay in Europe that industrialization did not solve all the problems of Europe . If it could not solve the problems of Europe, then
he genuinely believed industrialization
alone can never solve all the problems of more populous, basically rural India .
Hence it is important that village industries should also develop in conjunction
with big industries. Otherwise problems like urban migration and slums will
create their own problems. Importance of rural market and rural industry is
emphasized by modern day economists like CK Prahald in his Fortune at the Bottom
of the Pyramid. Successes like Prof Mohammed’s Bangladesh Grameena Bank also
emphasizes the importance of village industries even in modern era. At the same
time Mahatma in his time would not have imagined the invention of cell phones
or spread of internet which could reduce rural urban divide and world becomes a
global village.
It
is disgusting to see or hear the way the politicians, bureaucrats and intelligentsia
express their difference of opinion publicly on TV channels and the language
they use against one another. They are not even trying to act of emulating the
standards set by great leaders around 100 years ago. Mahatma is not alone in
this regard. Many leaders have done that. But it is best exemplified by arguably
the two greatest leaders of all time in India ,
Mahatma and Lokmanya. Two years before his demise Tilak requested Gandhi to
attend congress meeting. Gandhi politely declined his invitation telling him he
differs with Lokmanya and Mrs. Besant in their method of fighting. He also
acknowledged at the same time that both of them do believe Gandhi’s method
would not achieve the goal. Gandhi said he differs with moderates led by
Gokhale also and told that he strongly believes in his method of truth and
non-violence and would be patient so that people will also understand. At the same time he did want to tell in
congress public meeting and embarrass Tilak. He advised both moderates and
extremists also to state their positions publicly to people rather than
compromising on their fundamental beliefs to project the common face. At the
same time Gandhi organized a meeting to collect funds to compensate the loss
incurred by Tilak in his court battle against English man for public good. Mahatma always addressed
Tilak as Lokmanya and paid greatest tributes on his demise telling that Tilak
felt Swaraj as his passion and advanced the achievement of independence by many
years by his acts and deeds.
Mahatma’s
personal qualities and behavior like Simple living, Simple eating, Indriya
Nigraham (control of senses), renunciation, truthfulness, adherence to non-violence,
vegetarianism, courage, fighting for the oppressed, way of mingling with masses, leadership
qualities, of following Sanatana Dharma with the letter and spirit and patience
are like a saint and only word MAHATMA can best describe him.
Jim
Collins and his co-author propose a
theory of Yin-Yang in their book Built to Last which discusses the long
surviving and most successful companies. The secret of these companies is preserving the core and changing the rest
rather than trying to change everything.
So
as a nation we have to also preserve the core of the nation that is best
demonstrated by Mahatma. By writing all the above pages I don’t want to
immortalize Mahatma. Jawaharlal Nehru writes in Discovery of India that India immortalize its great scriptures and
people make them god to feel
satisfied that ordinary human beings need not ever try to follow them, because
god is too big to follow for ordinary. Western nations make their great people as
role models and our youth who are overawed by the west should follow west in
this aspect also and try to imbibe great qualities of Mahatma not only to pay
true tributes to him but for the very survival of our nation and democracy. On
this day of my conclusion I came across a news item in a telugu news
paper-Eenadu that the Chinese are teaching about Mahatma to their younger
generation to build a Good Character and a sense of direction to the whole
country for their future. Let us learn from others and imitate them as we only imitate from others and learn
about our greatness.
The
cause of today is the effect of past and cause of the future.
Whatever
you think that you will be. If you think yourself weak, weak you will be; If
you think yourself strong, strong you will be.
What
the world wants is character. The world is in need of those whose life is one
burning love, selfless. That love will make every word tell like thunderbolt .
-swami Vivekananda.
No comments:
Post a Comment